I decided the best way for me to critique the show would be to take notes as I listen to it and then to go back and reflect on the show with the questions provided. I listened to Wacky History. I think the name is very clever for the topic of the show.
Thoughts during the show
- Catchy intro music
- Wedding rings and something? Hard to understand the intro
- Voices change abruptly in volume
- First part:
- Dentures… interesting topic choice
- Easy to understand, good background music
- Editing isn’t smooth in some parts
- Light humor- I liked that
- Good transition and questions
- I like the talking back and forth
- George Washington part
- Very entertaining voice
- Likes this part
- Next part:
- Bland voice
- Background music VERY soft- hard to hear
- More questions and banter- like this
- The guy has a great voice- very good for his parts
- First Commercial is REALLY great
- Wacky history part
- Good music
- Very interesting
- History of wedding rings
- Seem unsure of what you are saying in the beginning
- Interesting information
- Good voices (changes tone/pitch in voice)
- Jewelry/wedding facts
- Multiple choice question- kinda cool
- Like the ticking noises
- Fly commercial
- liked it
- seat belt-car sound
- Where to put the ring
- sounded too far away from the mic sometimes
Quality of audio sound -e.g. is the volume appropriate? are the levels even? Is the sound clear, and free of noises not needed (e.g. mouse clicks, background noise)?
No noticeable background noise. The background music didn’t cancel out the talking. Levels somewhat uneven when switching from person to person.
Quality of audio editing – use of effects, transitions, are the edits clean?
Only noticed effects in the bumper. Background music is good. Transitions clean. I liked the questions in between the different topics.
Use of sound effects- how are they used? Is it effective?
Not much use of sound effects. When used good and effective.
Use of music- how is it used? Is it effective or distracting?
Music is very effective. It is at a good volume, so that it is noticeable, yet doesn’t wash out the speaker. Used throughout the whole podcast. Also used to signify changes in topics.
Does the show have a structure? Is it cohesive or does it feel stitched together?
Somewhat. I don’t think it’s bad or anything, I just think it could be better. I would have liked an emphasis on the connection of dentures and wedding rings. Good transitions make it cohesive.
Does it tell a story effectively? Is there a sense of drama, unknown? Does it draw you in to listen?
Tells little stories. Not really a sense of drama. The guys voice is very entertaining and draws you in. One of the girls used her voice very well when telling stories.
If you would rate this radio show, how many stars out of five would you give to the show
I would probably give the show 3.75 stars out of 5.